Care of Amish Farm Animals

Recently, I have had an online blog argument of sorts in our Battle Creek Enquirer about the treatment of Amish animals. This person states he has been witness to the Amish severly mistreating their animals and the SPCA having to remove them. This began after the most recent Amish Cook article about hog butchering with the family. He felt it was horribly cruel to have the children witness this event. My contention was it is part of their sustinance and probably more humane then the butchering of meat we purchase in the market.

Can anyone shed some light on this dispute for me?

Re: Care of Amish Farm Animals

My Grandfather was a cattle rancher.  His ranch was pretty far from where we lived, we usually visited in the summer, one year a calf was born while we were there, my sister and I were allowed to name him, Firecracker it was near the 4th of July.  However, I did know that my grandfather raised cattle, that were going to end up on someone's dinner table! 

Even though we live in suburbia we have raised our children to know this too, the Bible says that God put creatures on the earth for man to be sustained.  When we are out and about in rural areas and see a field of cattle, we will say, "there's steak on the hoof!"    

Re: Care of Amish Farm Animals

We have butchered our own cows, we always send our pigs to the slaughterhouse to be done but it is a very reputable one . We have also done our own deer meat & have had the SH do it also , There are so many variaties they can do to the meat we can't. I have always let my children witness birth as well as the death of an animal , Be it at our hands to cook & eat it or even if we had a animal that took sick an was passing away. Sometimes there are tears shed from myself as well as one of the children , But it is always a lesson learned , these are things that we shouldnt be shielding our children from because they are a part of life an growing up. It would be great if no one ever had to expirence death of any kind but thats pretty much impossible. So when you go thru things you always explain, answer questions, & if need be wipe tears away with kisses.  How are children supose to grow up an know anything if they dont expirence things in life, As a parent of grown children an now young stepchildren & also a very young grandchild. I would deffinitly rather be the one teaching them about life, then  throwing them out into the world with no clue about anything.

paulaayn's picture

Re: Care of Amish Farm Animals

Butchering day isn't a cruel tradition, it's not a tradition at all. It's how EVERYONE'S meat gets from the barn to the kitchen table!

This is what modern society seems to forget. Food doesn't just magically appear in the grocery store. That's what we farmers have to fight against. We raise our animals/crops, send them to market and don't get enough. The "Public" don't care because food is still in the stores. Most people are far too removed from the food chain and don't understand. All they think of animals as "Wilbur" and "Babe" not as pig #23 that's going to market/freezer tomorrow. That and they don't know how "food" animals are raised. Sometimes things need to be done that seem cruel, but there is always a reason.

Besides, like Luv says, Lovina's children do jobs that suit their ages. And speaking as a town girl married to a farmer, children raised with meat animals don't look at them like we "townies". They are "just animals" not cuddly "toys". I'm not saying they don't have feelings, they just understand the "circle of life".

I fully admit that there are cruel people out there that mistreat animals, just as there are people that mistreat children. The SPCA and the OSPCA do good work for the most part. But it also needs to be remembered that, at least here in Ontario, they are not fully trained in animal husbandry. They are given more power than the police and often that power goes to their heads. There have been more than a few cases in rural Ontario of the SPCA raiding a farm and taking all the animals, only to have the animals die in SPCA hands and those that manage to survive to be returned because the charges were unfounded.

doodles47's picture

Re: Care of Amish Farm Animals

AMEN paulaayn !!
My kids grew up on the farm and we butchered hogs and steers every year. Wish we could do it now, but my hubby isn't able to do it anymore. We now take our larger animals to the Menonites to process. It is a whole lot easier on me, but I miss it.
At least my kids knew what animal bacon, sausage, roasts etc. came from.

Re: Care of Amish Farm Animals

Wow, that is insane! I always enjoy hearing your info about farm life. :-)

Re: Care of Amish Farm Animals

Well said!

Re: Care of Amish Farm Animals

The problem with most of present day Americans is that they want to "personify" everything. I was raised around butchering,as were my kids, and now my grandkids. We always explained to our kids that pigs or cows to be butchered were not pets. Do not name them, unless you choose Pork chop or Bacon or Burger!! They have grown up without ill effects, and still eat meat! In fact, in an earlier post on this site, I mentioned that we had just butchered a pig. Animals at huge feed lots set for slaughter are the most apt to be "abused", yet they are the very ones at the supermarkets and McDonald's across America. Let the small farmers and the Amish alone to carry on traditions that have been long standing in our country. The way our economy is heading, I'll bet you see more home butchering, etc. in the near future.

Re: Care of Amish Farm Animals

That is really interesting. I figure the Amish children are just used to this as a normal part of life, and probably don't think too much of it. From what Lovina writes, it is really a family gather/event and a time of fellowship, also. My aunt would never let my younger girl cousins go outside when the guys had a deer hanging from a tree, ready to be butchered. I guess everyone is entitled to what they want to do with their children, but I guess I just don't see anything damaging to it.

Re: Care of Amish Farm Animals

LuvM is right, everyone is entitled to their opinion......I suppose you could argue that butchering day is a cruel tradition. But then we'd have to do away with Intuit traditions, Amazonian tribal traditions, Native American traditions...basically any culture that doesn't conform to Midwestern American standards is cruel...Yeah, the meat in a Hyvee or a Kroger or a Publix that is sooooo much more humane! Sorry for the sarcasm. Again, free country, anyone can think what they want...and, personally, I'd find butchering day very gross, but the fact is is that it is an important part of the Amish culture of sustenance and self-sufficieny...for Heavens Sake it's not like 3-year-old Kevin is digging out pig brains with his bare hands...the children, age accordingly, participate in small ways to start and they gradually more as they get older...that is how traditions get passed...

Re: Care of Amish Farm Animals

Also, and I am going to make a big assumption here, I figure that the children (at least the younger ones) are not around when they actually kill the animal. Personally, I don't think I would want to watch that, but I wouldn't have any issue in helping with the cutting up and processing/packing of the meat.

Re: Care of Amish Farm Animals

Have you ever done anything like it?? It is really physical labor. Think about how much she said they weighed. Even if someone else stronger made some basic separations, there is still a lot of weight to "finagle around" to create the various cuts of meat. And that is before they start wrapping for the freezer and then all that canning she spoke about..........

Re: Care of Amish Farm Animals

I did help a bit when I was younger, but usually just packaging up hamburger. Now, I do help hubby cut up a deer when he gets one. Definitely something I wouldn't want to do everyday! :-)

Post new comment

The content of this field is kept private and will not be shown publicly.
  • Lines and paragraphs break automatically.
  • Web page addresses and e-mail addresses turn into links automatically.
  • Allowed HTML tags: <iframe> <p> <br> <br /> <a> <em> <strong> <cite> <code> <ul> <ol> <li> <dl> <dt> <dd> <img> <object> <param> </param> <embed> <span> <div>
  • You may post PHP code. You should include <?php ?> tags.

More information about formatting options

CAPTCHA
This question is used to make sure you are a human visitor and to prevent spam submissions.
Image CAPTCHA
Copy the characters (respecting upper/lower case) from the image.